Assessments
Claim by claim
MSF reports more than 420 war-wounded admissions at Korem and Alamata and more than 300 at Shire through 25 September.
Claimed by Médecins Sans Frontières · source rating
B2
likely
55–80%
MSF reports from the medical response it supports. This is a direct operational account, but we have not audited patient records.
What complicates it
Admissions are not deaths. Civilian/combatant breakdown and possible transfers between facilities are not established here.
What would change our mind
A corrected MSF update or reconciled hospital records with dates and patient-transfer information would change this assessment.
MSF reported on 28 September that its Alamata hospital activities and outreach activities were suspended.
Claimed by Médecins Sans Frontières · source rating
B2
likely
55–80%
The organisation describes its own activities in its dated update.
What complicates it
This does not establish that the entire hospital closed, that all providers stopped work, or that the suspension continues today.
What would change our mind
A dated MSF clarification, service-resumption notice or independently documented service status would change this assessment.